Canadian
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's father, Pierre Elliot Trudeau, held
that same position from 1968 until 1984. P.E.T. was famous for a line
he delivered when asked how far he'd go in imposing martial law and
suspending civil liberties to deal with a terrorist threat from an
extremist organization (the FLQ) during what was called The October Crisis in 1970. His answer was, "Just watch me."
Recently,
I googled that now famous quote, to hear it in in context. I never
doubted that the decision to invoke the War Measures Act was justified;
and so it was a surprise to me to hear Pierre Trudeau make several
statements that I'm not comfortable with.
The video of that impromptu interview:
1)
Trudeau said, "If it hasn't affected you, personally, yet ... then why
should you be concerned?" What is that? Is than an appeal to look away
when an injustice is being done to someone else? Actually, I think it's
more an appeal to the "normalcy bias",
which is a rationalization people use to deal with threats or
disasters; the flawed logic being that if something hasn't happened yet,
there's no reason to believe that it will. Trudeau was basically
appealing to this state of mind, I believe. Pay no attention, he was
saying, to that man behind the curtain.
3)
Finally, Trudeau tries to denigrate the young reporter who expressed
concern for a free society as a "bleeding heart." The young CBC
reporter (Ted Ralfe), who was just 32 at the time, had expressed his own opinion that "This is about choices. My
choice is to live in a society that is free and democratic," and one of
the things, he said, that we have to give up for that choice is the
absolute safety and security of a police state. He had a valid point ...
the choice he perceived, between the abandonment of liberty in the
pursuit of security is another that's become a recurrent one.
Personally, I think he was expressing a courage that says, "no, I'm not
willing to yield my liberty for the promise of safety." I agree with
him, now more than ever before in my entire life. I'm not afraid of
ISIS, or Russia, or whoever they hold up before as an "imminent threat"
to our safety. ISIS has never harmed me; or anyone I know or care
about, or anyone I will ever know or care about. It won't happen. It's
such a remote possibility, it isn't even worth worrying about. I do
know, however, know that my liberty, my natural rights as a human being,
are being threatened, and have been attacked. That's a real concern;
and an immediate concern. That young man was absolutely right to make
liberty the more important concern to Canadians. While the War Measures
Act was in effect, 465 Canadians were arrested and held without charge.
Canadians
have often reminded me of the elder Trudeau's imposition of martial
law, in which Canadians were arrested, without charges, and denied legal
recourse. It was Pierre E. Trudeau who began concentrating power in
the Prime Minister's Office. Unlike Americans, though, Canadians are
not willing to allow the use of a perpetual state of war and "emergency
wartime" measures to justify the imposition of a permanent
police/security/surveillance state.
No comments:
Post a Comment